Best Landlord Insurance In New York For Your Rental Property (Rates from $138/month!)

UpdatedDecember 29, 2023

Top Choice:

Progressive  Landlord Insurance

5.

progressive logo

Progressive is an A+ Superior rated company and is known as one of the most ethical insurance companies. Along with helping you shop around for coverage, they also have the "Name Your Price" tool which creates quotes based on your budget.

Key Features: 

  • Online Approval In Minutes | 100% Online Process
  • Coverage For Your Home Office
  • Condo Insurance Available
  • Secure and Simple Application Process

Owning a rental property in New York can be a lucrative investment, but it also comes with risks, such as statewide vacancy rates of 6.8%, disasters, and accidents.

And whether you're a first-time landlord or have years of experience, you know that rental property insurance is necessary, but the cost varies depending on where you may live and the insurance company you choose.

In this post, we'll cover the best landlord insurance in New York, how much landlord insurance you'll need, and help you find the most affordable home insurance quotes for rental property from companies in NY.

More Of The Best Landlord Insurance Companies In New York Below:

How Much Does New York Landlord Insurance Cost?

The average monthly cost of landlord insurance in New York is $138 or about $1,651 per year. However, bear in mind that the final price will vary for all landlords depending on where you reside, your building, liability coverage options, your credit history, deductible, and other plan options.

Factors That Affect Your New York Rental Insurance Quotes

There are several factors that insurance companies consider when you're getting a quote. Below, we cover some of the most important ones, which are:

Your Building - The age of your property determines the cost of your insurance coverage. Is there any water in the pipes? When was the roof last replaced? Is it copper wiring or aluminum wire?

Your Location - When it comes to determining your rental insurance rates, one of the most important factors that insurance companies consider is the location of your house.

Credit History - You have a distinct credit score for insurance products developed specifically for you. Your rates will be lower if your credit score is higher. However, some states no longer allow insurance companies to use your credit to determine rates. 

Coverage Levels - When you start reviewing quotes, you will see that each insurance provider will let you choose various coverage options.

Deductibles - A deductible is another alternative that you may customize to your budget. A deductible is a sum you must pay before insurance pays out.

What Type Of Liability Coverage Should A Landlord Carry In New York?

In New York, there are three distinct types of rental property insurance coverage to consider. They're known as "forms," and each has a different degree of coverage.

What Are The Different Types Of Landlord Insurance Cover In New York?

Below we discuss the different types of landlord insurance coverages in detail:

DP1 - Dwelling

A named-peril policy (DP-1) is an insurance policy that protects you against a specific hazard. This implies the policy will pay for only those events expressly included in the coverage wording, and your insurance coverage will not compensate for anything else.

DP2 - Replacement Cost

The (DP-2) policy will give you more coverage than the DP-1. This is accomplished by extending the range of additional perils and providing reimbursement on a replacement cost rather than a cash value cost basis.

DP3 - Open Peril

The most popular landlord insurance policy is a DP-3 policy, an open peril policy. An Open Peril Policy means your coverage will cover damage caused by anything other than items on the prohibited list.

THE SIMPLY INSURANCE WAY

Landlord Insurance made easy.

Agents not required.

Get quotes and sign up online without talking to an agent. But, we are here if you need us. 

Unbiased, expert advice.

Get unbiased insurance education from licensed experts and also avoid dodgy sales calls.

Coverage in minutes.

You can get Landlord insurance coverage within minutes of getting your quotes and applying.

What Perils Does Landlord Insurance New York Cover You For?

If you're renting a property, your landlord insurance policy will cover the structure and land and provide enhanced general liability insurance to ensure you don't have to worry about legal costs. If your home becomes uninhabitable, your income loss protection will come into action, reimbursing the rent that your tenant was supposed to pay.

Property Damage

Standard rental insurance includes this sort of coverage to repair or replace your property after a covered loss, such as fire, vandalism, or natural calamity.

Loss Of Use Coverage

If your property becomes uninhabitable because of issues such as a sinkhole, mold, or termites, your landlord policy rent loss coverage will come into play and pay you the rental income that a tenant would have paid.

Liability Protection: 

Liability protection covers the medical bills or legal expenses incurred by a tenant or visitor if they are injured due to an apartment building care problem.

Specific Perils That Can Be Covered By A Rental Policy:

You may select a broader range of coverage on your insurance policy or opt for a restricted variety of coverages at a lower price.

  • Water
  • Fire
  • Windstorm & Hail
  • Lightning
  • Lawsuits
  • Vandalism & theft
  • Riot and civil commotion
  • Injury

Does Homeowners Insurance Cover Rental Properties?

No, A standard home insurance policy will not cover any income losses or liability claims resulting from a renter residing in their home while they are away on vacation, at work, or otherwise. If you own an investment property that's rented out full time, landlord insurance rather than the usual homeowners policy is required for the protection of your business property.

What Type Of Rental Properties Will A Landlords Insurance Policy Insure?

A landlord insurance policy will usually provide coverage for all sorts of rental dwellings, ranging from single-family homes to apartment complexes, including vacant, undergoing renovations, or being converted into a rental property. They can also cover AirBNBs and similar rentals.

What Is Not Covered By Rental Property Insurance?

Although landlord insurance is a certain safeguard for landlords to rent out their property, it does not cover everything. The following is a lists of conditions that landlord insurance does not generally cover:

Flooding: Regardless of whether a flood occurs due to natural phenomena or an accident, you will need to buy flood insurance to cover those specific costs.

Maintenance repairs: If an appliance, such as a stove or dishwasher, breaks down and doesn't work correctly, landlord insurance will not cover the repairs or the money to buy a new one.

Renter's Personal Property: If the landlord fails to maintain the rental property and causes damage to the tenants' possessions, and as a result, landlord insurance will not cover it. We recommend requiring all of your renters to obtain renters insurance to safeguard their belongings.

Careless Tenants: Landlord insurance may not always cover irresponsible renters who fail to maintain your rental house properly. Property owners may have to consider additional protection against these sorts of claims.

Do I Need Landlord Insurance By Law In New York?

In New York, landlord insurance is not required by law, but it is a brilliant idea to get it. It's a good idea to acquire landlord insurance if you rent and maintain your possessions because landlord insurance helps protect against the unexpected. It is important to note that your homeowner's policy will most likely not cover any losses or damages caused by you or your renters.

Who Should Buy New York Rental Insurance?

Anyone who rents out their property or properties should have landlord insurance (also known as rental property insurance). Mainly because it may provide you with several advantages, including:

  • Financial protection against natural disasters
  • Protection against a tenant getting injured on your property
  • Coverage for fire and water damage
  • Coverage against legal liability

Can A Landlord Require Renters Insurance In New York?

Yes, as a Landlord, you can require your tenants to purchase renters insurance in New York, and it's a win-win situation for everyone involved.

LANDLORD INSURANCE WHERE YOU LIVE

Landlord insurance by state.
Protecting your new rental or investment property should be a top priority.

Click on your state to get a free landlord insurance quote and make sure that you're fully protected.

AlabamaALAlaskaAKArizonaAZArkansasARCaliforniaCAColoradoCOConnecticutDelawareFloridaFLGeorgiaGAIdahoIDIllinoisILIndianaINIowaIAKansasKSKentuckyKYLouisianaLAMaineMEMarylandMassachusettsMichiganMIMinnesotaMNMississippiMSMissouriMOMontanaMTNebraskaNENevadaNVNew HampshireNew JerseyNew MexicoNMNew YorkNYNorth CarolinaNCNorth DakotaNDOhioOHOklahomaOKOregonORPennsylvaniaPARhode IslandSouth CarolinaSCSouth DakotaSDTennesseeTNTexasTXUtahUTVermontVirginiaVAWAWest VirginiaWVWisconsinWIWyomingWYVermontVTNew HampshireNHMassachusettsMAConnecticutCTNew JerseyNJMarylandMDHawaiiHIRhode IslandRIDelawareDE

How To Get Your Free Landlord Insurance Quote In New York?

If you're a landlord in New York, it's critical to have the right kind of insurance for your property.  Landlord insurance protects tenants and landlords from liability during typical business operations and mistakes.

The best and fastest way to get your free landlords insurance quote is to click here or on any of the above buttons to obtain some instant rental property insurance quotes and be protected immediately.

Frequently Asked Questions About New York Rental Insurance


How much is landlord insurance in New York?

The national average cost for landlord insurance policies in New York is around $126 per month or $1,516 per year. However, landlord insurance costs around $138 per month or $1,651 per year in New York. Generally, larger metropolitan areas can be expected to pay higher policies.

Is landlord rental insurance worth it?

Landlord insurance is worth it as a landlord to mitigate your risk and protect yourself from financial loss. However, you should always ensure that the monthly premium doesn't cost more than what your property brings in on average every month; otherwise, it won't be worth the cost of coverage.

Is Geico landlord insurance good?

Yes, Geico is a great option for landlords to purchase rental property insurance. However, It's also worth noting that you should definitely review multiple quotes from multiple companies for the best rates. We like Progressive for landlord insurance in NY.

What insurance is a landlord responsible for in NY?

A landlord in New York is only responsible for the insurance on the building itself and not the property's contents. To cover their property, tenants need a renter's policy or an umbrella policy.

EXPERT EDITOR & REVIEWER

Sa El

Licensed & Certified Insurance Agent

Sa El is the Founder of Simply Insurance and a licensed Insurance Agent with over 15 years of experience in the industry.  He specializes in Life & Health Insurance and is certified in Long Term Care Insurance in the state of Georgia. a licensed real estate agent in the state of Georgia (License #382602), an entrepreneur, insurance educator, and freelance writer.